pa3pa6ornr <<Cxemsr pa3BHTr.iq H pa3Meil{eunfi sJler{Tpo3ueprerltKH)>
H CXetorbI KOb{TIJIeKCHOfO }iCilO/rbSOBaHHfl H OXpaHbI BOAHbIX pecypcoB
npH ilpoBeAeHHH pacqeroB 3Kolror{?rqecxofi eQQexrnBHocTH Ao[y-
cKalorcfl yrrpoil{eHHfi. Cocrae T3O {T3P) Ha pa3rHr{HbIX arallax H
craAuflx [poeKTlipoBaHnfi 6un npnBeAen e r,'i. 19.
2I.2. 3T(OI-IOM',I'.IECHOE CPABHEHHE BAPIIAHTOB
Mero4 cpaBHprrerrnuofi 3KoHoM[rqecxofi eQQexruBHocrn 3aK,'Iio-
qaeTCfl B corrocTaBiIeHHH eAlIHoBpeMeHHbIX KaIiliTaJIOenoxeHHl't H
elKefoAHbIX I{3Aep)fieK IIo CpaBHHBaelvlhIM BapHaHTaIvI TeXHHT{ecKllx
peueHafi o6rexroe.
Han6o.rree o6uuu sBJlflercfi cnyvafi, KorAa BaplIaHT o6'rexra
fHIp03HepfocTpoHTe;lbcTB? xapariTepH3yeTc.fi 6o.nrurnuli KarIlITa/lo-
BJ'lOlKeHllfMH, HO MeHbIIIIIMH eX{efOAHbiMH H3Aep)KI(aMH, rIeM 3aMe-
useurtft BaDHaHT.
fiorasaieJreM cpaBHr{Tellnoii eQQexrHBHocrn KariHTaJroBJIox(e-
ssft flB,Tfiercfl MHHHMyM rtpHBeAeHHbrx 3arpar, xoropltit tto
Kax{Aorvry BappraHry nPeAcran.rlfleT co6ofi cyMMy e }K e r o A H bI x
H 3A e p )K eK npolr3BoAcrBa (ce6ecrouMocrb npoayxuNn) H KanHra-
JroB.,TOlK€Hrit"r, rrpHBeAeHHbrx K oAnsaxoeofi pa3MepHocrH B coorBe'f-
crBuli c HopMarHBoM oQ 0 eKTHBHocrlr to.
flpuee4eHnble 3arparbr orpeAerffrorcfi no Qopnyne
fAe To - oasncHurti roAi / - rexyruuft roA; f, - roA I-IaqaJIa 3KC-
rrJryaTar{Hi{ oO".i.rr i E^.n- Hoprunaru* yqera Saxrop a BpeMeHI'I;
Kt - KarIHTaJrOB,'rox(eH1{fl B roA t- Ann paccNlaTpHB.aeMofo BapHaHTa;
a,Ht- H3MeHeHHe ex{efoAHblx H3Aepx(eK B foA / no cpaBHeHHIO c
rrpeAbIAyuIHM roAOM AJIff p accMarpHBaeM-o.fo. BapI'laHTa'^ 
B 6bnee npJcrovr'u".1,. $opniyny (2L2) MolKHo 3aIIHCarb:
3:E#+14,
rAe 3, K, H - COOTBSTCTBeHI{O IIpHBeAeHHbIe 3aTpaTbI, Ka[liTaJIoBJIO-
)KeHHfl H elKefoAHbre H3Aepx{KlI c yrIeToM Qarropa BpeMeHH'
B erofi QoPvtYle
/91 q\
Anq Bcex cpaBHHBaeMbIX o6lextoe orcr{er
I
7-Snrtrr\ -- 4_l .\i\- |
I -l
a,-t 
T
E. _)'6-,: kf : ) Lkl t"fi nl 
t:l ^
(l +Eu'n)--t'
JIeT npoH3BOAHTCff OT
3 i:EoKi* H i,
rAe 3; - IIpHBeAeHHbre 3aTparhr rro oAHoMy H3 paccillaTpHBaei!{brx
BapHaHroB i; EE- uopuarueHurl xo:SQnqneHr sQQexrxBHocrH Ka-
TIHTA.TIOBJ'IOXCUiTii; Kt _ KAIIHTAJIOBJIO}KCHHg NO BAPHAHTY i; lI i _
ex\efoAlrbre HsAeplr(KH npor{3BoAcTBa (ce6ecrolrMocTb npoayxurtu)
no BapHaHry ,.
Ecrn cpaBHHBaeMb{e BapHaHTbr rexHHqecKHX peueHufi H o6ter<-
TOB, HaMeqaeMbrx K ocyqecrBJleHHro, oTJlHqalorcfl He ToJIbKo pa3NIe-
paMH Heo6xoAnMbrx 3aTpar, Ho cpoKaMH coopyx{eHuff H ocBoeHHfl
npoei<rHofi MouIHocrH, To garparbr pa3Hbrx neT npHBoAflTCfi K KaKo-
*ry-ru6o oAHoil{y 6asncuolty roAy, B KaqecrBe Koroporo Mox(er 6rrrn
irpHirar nn6ofi ro,u,.
B o6qeu cJryqae, KorAa KaiIHTaJIoBJIox(eHHg B elKeroAHbre H3-
AeplKKli ilpoI{3BoAcTBa H3MeHsrOTCfl IIO fOAaN{ paCr{eTHOfO rrepH0Aa
T, ea npeAeJlaMrr Koroporo, r. €. HaqHHafl c roAa (T+l), paccMar-
pHBaeil{ble o6r,exru He tpe6yror KanHTaiTonlo}KeHHi"r, a e}KeroA}rbre
H3AepX(r{H npor{3BoAcTBa ocTaroTcs nocTo.fiHHbrMH Ann KaxAofo H3
cpaBiIr.IBaeMbrx BaptraHToB (Hr:H r+t) , npHBeAeHr-rbte 3arparbr c
yqeroM Sar<ropa BpeMeHH B paccMarpr.rBaeMoM BapHar{Te per(o;\,reH-
Ayercfl onpeAenflrb rro Qoprvly.rue
TT
E - tr Sn'rtJ-tr \-6-'' Iv:--rt/-)..r\r-rurr.n) f I AH,(l +Er..)'u-t, (21.2)
f:l t:t^
oAHOfO I-I TO|O Xie foAa.
Coopyx<eHrre friApo3HeprerttqecKoro o6.oexra flpli3Haercfl sQQer-
THBHbtNt, ecJirr IIpHBeAeHHbIe 3aTpaTbi r{o HeMy, iloAcIIHTal]Hble no
qop*rynu* (ZL.ti H (21.3), oxasitnarcrcfl MeHbtuIINlII, qeivf npllBeAeH-
Hble 3aTpaTbI no 3aIVIeFifleMoMy BapHaHTy, noAcllHTaHtIL,Ie no TeM X{e
Qopuyrau.
Texglrxo-3KoHoN,rrrqeCKHe paCqeTbI IIo oIIpeAeJIeHHIo HapoAHoxo'
ssl'rcreeuHor:i e$QexrnBHOCTH BoAO XO3 s ti cTBeH H blx K o M Ii'
"oa^aO" (BXI() 3aK,TiOr{aIoTCf, TaK X(e KaIi u AIlfi rl{Apo3HepreTii-
qeCKlIX O6terrOg, e COIOCTaB.IeH]iH npI{Be,[,eHHbIX 3aTpaT' HeO6XOAI{-
MbtXAJ]flocyiqecTBjleH}IflBoAoXo3ffI"ICTBeH.i{oroKo]vtIIJIeKCa,cTeMH
[pr{BeAeHHbII\'Itr 3aTpaTaM}I, KOTopbIe noTpe6OeaIHCu 6nt AJiq OcyUeC'r-
BJIeHnfl Su*ranr.*"* (allrepuarHnHux) O6leKroe BNIeCTO paccMaT-
priBae\{blx BXK.''--npr 
*uro*r t{HSJIe'BapHaHT6B Bo3MoH{Ho TaKx(e nonapHoe HK
cpaBHeHHe no MeroAy cpbra oKynaeMocTH (xoaQQul{HeH-
T'a 3 Q Q e KT 'BHocrH) KanHTaJIoB.IIoiKeHllri. TorAa
(21.1)
(21.4)
(21.5)
390