Asanorn.rHHrl noAxor, B Hacroflrqee Bpeil{r ocyqecrBfiflercfi H Ii
npodaevre yAoBJrerBopeHufl Hyx{A KoM My}I a,r'lbHo ro xosfl ft cr'
8fl, CaHHTapHbIX, SKOiIOrHqe CTKHX H peKpeaUHOHHbIx
rpe6onaHult.
fl'pn arou ocoderuHo BaxiHbrM sBJrflerc4 Bonpoc Bbrno/rHeHnfl rpe-
lpe6onauHg B Haerosu{ee BpeMfi He on'peA.efiflercfi KaKHMH-JrH6o .{He-
.IIoBbnMH noKa3areJlflMH. QopuHpoBaHHe KaqecrBeHHbIX KpHTepHeB Ha-
xoAHTcff Ha HaqalrbHoM 3Tane H npeAcraBJrffer co6ofi o6.nacm [ocJre-
AylolrIHX HccJr eAo B a uu fi .
Bce BblrrreneperiHcreHHbie r{pHTepHH MoryT 6urs HcnoJlbgoBaHbr c
rIoJIHbrM ripaBoM JrHrrrb B Tex cJryqaflx, KorAa BoAoxo3sficteeHHsrrl
KoMrIJreKc HMeer ffpKo nnrpaxeuuur? oAHooTpac,'renofi xaparffep a
rpe6oeauHr norpe6Hre.rleil IpyrHX orpacler? ln6o Moryr 6urn 6e:
3aMerHoro yulep6a yAoBJrerBopeHbr, .nli6o Moryr He npHHn,Marbcfi Bo
BHHMAHHE.
OAHaxo a6co.nrorHoe 6o.ruunncfBo BoAoxo3sficreeunstx KoMnJreK-
coB, B [epByro osepeAb KpyflHrilx, HMero-T spKo Bbrpaxie]IiHnr? r'l H o r o-
o rp a c Jr e n b ft x a p a K T e p H Hcrro.rrb3oBaHHe BoAHbrx pecypcoB
fl BJIfi CTCfi KO MIJI EKCHbIM.
B 3ToM cflyqae HcnoJrb3yrorcff ABa noAXoAa K
KpHrepHeB.
flepnufi noAXoA xx,psKTe pH3yercr QopuupoBaHHei!,r K o M rr Jr e K c-
Horo 3KoHo'MHqecKoro KpHTepHfl B Qopne eseeuleHHori
cyMMbr paccMorpeHHbrx KpHTepHeB
ar : 
"{ 
r,o' } extr.
O,quaKo BCe 6orsuree qHcno HccneAoBarenefi cxoAnTcfl Bo MHeHLrr{,IITO EC[OJ{b3oBaHHe TaKOTO KFHTepHfl npaBoMepHo B OrreHb OrpaHH-qeHHoM rrHcJre cnyqaeB B cBrr3H c oTcyTcTBHeM MeTOAOB OnpeAeneHHs
trlHoxurelefi 4.u, a raKxie HeoKBHBaJIeHTHocrbro npoAyr(uHn pa3flHr{-
Hbrx orpac"neir H HenpaBoMepHocrbro ee cpaBHeHHfl B o6udeu cJryqaerrep$ croHMocrb HJrlr qeHy KaKofo-rs6o nuAa.
Broporl noAXoA cBfl3ax c SopvrHpoBaHHeM cHcreMbr oTpacJre-
BbIX KpHTepHeB Anf pelueHHfi MHofoKpHTepuaJrbHofi saAacH dfl-
THMH3ar{HH pacnpeAeJreHHs 'BOAHbTX pecypcoB. llpnuepou raxoft cH-
creybr KpHrepHeB Mox(er cnylriHrb rrpHH.sraff rrpH paepa6orxe ACVE
p. flHenpa H Bxrrroqanu{afl:
rHAPosHeprerHqecxufi xprtrepHt? - ilraKcHMyM Bbrpa6orxn sneKTpo-
3HeprHH;
opocnreJrtuufi xpHrepuri - MHHHMyM yulep6oe B oporxeHur{ npu
cHHXieHH H BoAoorAl v u -HHlKe rpe6yeivroft ;pu6oxo:nficrseuHlrfi xprirepnn -_ Mar{cHMyM yJroBa pu6rr 3a ne-
pHoA T ner;
Tpalicnoprllryl'r xpurepni? -_MlrHHMyM yuep6on B peqHoM rpaHc-
nopre npH cpa6or.xe ypoBHfl KpeueuuyrcKoro BoAoxpaHHnHrr{a gHi{(e
rIaBHf arIHoHHOfO.
294
QOpMHpOBaHr,rrc
Peruenne MHOroKpHTepHaJIbnbIX 3aAaq npeAcTaBJIfeT H3BeCTHyto
rpyAHocrb B cBf3H c o'IcyrcrBHeM o6u{ero Qopua"rbHoro MeroAa'
fip.l.ruB,,Iflercfl Bo3,Mor(HbiM crporoe onpeAerleFlne ilHL[lb 
"ti:::l::"io6;r3cTn HeXyAlxHX perueHilir - o6n acrl flapero, BHyrpl{ I{oTopoH
H3MeHeHLIe [epeMeHHbIX, 11pHBoAnU{HX K rpe6yervroMy yBeJlHrIeHHIo OA-
Horo trs KpHrepHeB, HelisdexHo BeAer K HelxeJlareilbHoMy cnlT:nl:"
Kp llTep Hfl li{l{ fl BJIfl toTcff cneAyrcU{He:
IVIaKCHMyN{ HaKOnJ'IeHHti BOAHbIX pecypcoB KacKaAoM BOAOXpaHH-
JIHUI B nepllol no,'lOsoAHil H naBOAKoB, npHqerw o6lelr HK B Kax(AoM
tr3 BOJ.OXpaHHd,'IrrUI Ha3rraqaeTCfl B cooTBeTcTBI{H C efo 3HaqHMOCTbIO
rr onpererflercfi BecoBbINI xo:QQlrutlerrrolt l.;;
MHHitllyl!{- XO;-IOCTbIX c6pocOn B KacKaAe BOAOXpaHIIIIHUI-KpHTe-
plr11, c"t:ilt"otfi c onrHMI-l3aUHefi pa6oru KacKaAa f3C u o6ecneqx-
Barcurlrir saron;reHlle BoAbI B BoAoxpaHHJIlluIaK;
MIIHIIMyM oTK,'IoHeHrtir napaMerpoB peX(HMa pa6oru BXK oT Onpe-
AeJrfleMoro rpe6oBattHff yqacrHuKoe BXK.
lloc.rrelgllft xpnrepHir nau6olee coorBercJ_eyer o6ufeft 3aAaqe
ynpaBJreHHfl Bor,HbrMH pecypcal.rg,^periaeMoft MuHncrePcrBoM MeJIHo-
pauHrr H BoAHoro xoaqr:rcisa CCCP. OAuaxo nonyqeHre QyHrunit
BairiHocTn yqacrHuKoB X1 ffBJineTcfl TpyAHopa3peunMol't 3aAaqel"I, 3a'
eHcsu{eft oT B3rJIfiAa Ha npO6,r"re,vry JIHI{a, npHHHMarog{ero peuleHge,
a cneAoBare,'IbHo, AonycKalou{eit HsnecrHblft npoH3BoJI'
Auaaus paccil.oTpeHHbtx KpuTepueS noKasillaeT, LtTo I HacTont4ee
sperwtt orc1rcTsger AHu7epcant udrrt rcptnepufi., no3lonnrct4urt cfuop'
ily/tuposarb tL Qop,uantrsolaTb sadaag nnatupoeaHun u AnpaBneHLI'fl
np u Ko/{nneKCHo.\t ucnortbsoEaHuLt eodttaw pecapcoE.
BHAHlvro, npn peuIeHHH srofi 3aAaqa CneAyeT paccMaTpHBarb He-
cKoJrbKo KpHTepHee, o6ecfleqliBaFOU{HX BcecropoHHocrb aHaJIH3a H xa-
paKrepHbIX Anfl KoHKperuofo BXK, H eu6op oKoHriaTeJlbuofo ynpaB'
nelrqecKoro pe[IeHHfl Bo3JIO]KHTb Ha JIHIIO, Hecyqee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb
3a efo IIOcneAcTBHf.
OneparnBHoe rrJraHHpoBaHHe. CneuuQnxoft oilepaTHBHoro nJIaHH-
poBaHHn HcnoJrb3oBaHtrf BOAHbrx pecypcoB no oTHoLIIeHHIO K Aonfo-
cpoqHorvry nJrarrHpoBaHHrc flBJrfeTcff MaJraf AnHTeJIbllocTb nnaHHPo-
BaHtrfl H noBuueHHe rpe6oeaulrirlx ero roqHocrlt. Srlr o6crogre"nn-
crBa rropo)riAaror ABa cyqecrBeHrrbrx MoMeHTa: Bo-nepBbIX, Heo6xoAH-
MOCTb yqeTa AHHaMHKTI ,rr,BrriKeHUrr BOJIlt flonycKoB lI naBOAKOB nO
295